Conditions of Use

A DIFFERENT VIEW OF REALITY:
Isolation and information

Jennifer Cram

First National Conference on Building a Better Future for Regional Australia
Whyalla South Australia 20-22 April 1994

© 1994. Originally published in First National Conference on Building a Better Future for
Regional Australia Whyalla South Australia 20-22 April 1994 Proceedings

ABSTRACT: Paper redefines isolation and access in relation to libraries, library materials and information, looks at a range of assumptions underlying traditional solutions and proposes a systems approach to meeting the information needs of regional Australia.

Mark Twain said of Australian history that it did not read like history at all, but

like the most beautiful lies; and all of a fresh sort, no mouldy old stale ones. It is full of surprises and adventures, and incongruities, and contradictions and incredibilities; but they are all true, they all happened. [1]

Isolation

The phrase the tyranny of distance encapsulates many of those surprises and adventures. But it is also the reason Australians understand immediately the joke inherent in the claim made by the Irish Club in Mt Isa that it is within walking distance of Melbourne, a claim based on the fact that the explorers Burke and Wills made the journey on foot.

The tyranny of distance is a phrase which was coined to emphasise the isolation of our island continent from the rest of the world, rather than the isolation experienced by much of rural Australia relative to the urbanised coastal fringe.

It is in the bush that we really come to understand what isolation can mean. When young teachers are posted to remote communities in the Kimberley region of Western Australia, their employment package includes an "insanity flight". The Ministry of Education has decided that more than one annual flight out is needed for a teacher to survive a full stint in a place with few facilities, intense heat, and perhaps one or two other teachers for English-speaking adult company. Residents of places like Fitzroy Crossing, though the town is large enough to support a District High School, have to go to Broome, 400 km away, to do their banking.

Isolation is one's sense of the difference between here and there. The longer it takes to bridge the intervening gap, the further apart here and there are in time, the greater the potential isolation. The world's most remote public telephone is at William Creek, South Australia. But once you make it to that phone and put through a call you have cancelled out the distance between William Creek and Washington, Warsaw, Wuhan or Wilcannia.

Developments in transportation and in telecommunications have progressively diminished our isolation. Nonetheless a combination of other factors has contributed to a drift from rural to urban areas, even in our most decentralised state, Queensland, which also has the largest habitable area of any state in Australia. The driving factors include rural mechanisation, economic recession, drought, and the creation of effective road, rail and air transport corridors between the coastal centres.

Rationalisation has seen the closure or downgrading of post offices, branches of banks, and schools all over the country. When the bank and the post office go, says the conventional wisdom, towns start to die. As one wag put it:

People are capital on legs. If they aren't properly attended to, your business will simply walk away. [2]

The drift is the result of a perception that the quality of life is better in the city, that opportunities exist there which do not exist in the country.

I want to pause here to caution you against reacting to this drift as if it is a crisis. Culturally Australians are funny people, and, despite the apparent homogenising cultural influence o f the American sitcom, culturally very different to Americans when it comes down to what motivates us.

The way to energise a group of Americans is to have a crisis. But Australians are more likely to be demotivated by a crisis, which is why when Australian managers latch on to American solutions, such as Tom Peters' Thriving on chaos, totally suspend their capacity for critical disbelief, and attempt to introduce these solutions into Australian organisations, the results are invariably extremely disappointing.

Australians are motivated more by a (small c) cause. As a nation, we are very generous in our giving to others in trouble. For us, the primal (small c) cause is that of mateship, of egalitarian treatment, of fairness; all those things that make up a true community, as opposed to a conglomeration of people who just happen to live in the same locality.

The Rand Committee has reported to the National League of Cities that the perceived attractiveness or quality of life of a community is its most cost-effective community resource [3]. Rural areas have to compete with cities to attract growth, jobs, economic development. The quality and availability of information and educational resources in a community are assets which enhance its ability to compete.

But are our assumptions about where advantage really lies, valid? When reviewing organisations or developing strategic plans, I have always found it useful to identify assumptions. Changing a way of thinking changes reality. For example, the Heinz company was able to put a perceived disadvantage to advantage. Because its ketchup was a lot slower than others it had a problem. Heinz ketchup was harder to pour because it was thicker. Therefore it was thought that the ketchup must taste a lot better. By advertising this point of view. Heinz turned a potential disadvantage into an advantage and market share rose from 19 percent to 50 percent [4] .

It is particularly useful to examine our assumptions about what is beneficial and what is not, and to ensure that we take a systems view in reaching a conclusion. It is imperative that we routinely take a systems view to overcome the inclination to embrace either/or thinking and its attendant search for a single answer.

The basic tenet of that which is referred to as systems theory, though it is in actuality not a theory but a fact, is that everything is a system. Even the atom, not so long ago thought to be the irreducible element of matter, is now found to be a system whose complexities nuclear physicists have hardly begun to unravel. On a level more macroscopic than atoms or individuals, all of us are component parts of the fabric of human society. And we are now coming to understand something Aboriginal people have known for many thousands of years - that the whole of that society is connected to the waters, to the land, to the forests, to the atmosphere. Nothing happens in isolation, and on multiple levels everything affects and is affected by everything else.

Regional Australia has to rethink current concepts of comparative advantage and disadvantage. It has to grasp the significance of the information industry and recognise that while the information society is well and truly upon us, and the learning society, a situation in which people are empowered and enabled to learn what, where, when and they like, throughout their lifespan, is for the most part an unrealised dream, the learning community is eminently more achievable.

Paul Hawken suggests that:

If every company on the planet were to adopt the environment and social practices of the best companies ... the world would still be moving toward degradation and collapse. [5]

The paradox is that creating a profitable company puts an intolerable strain on the natural world. The same paradox applies to cities and towns. In part, this results from the way we define profit. Think about the way we construct the Gross National Product. Because we add to the GNP the profits on vehicle repair, medical expenses, funeral costs and re- insurance, car accidents are actually assumed to be good for the economy.

Enjoying enhanced quality of life embodies reclaiming an understanding of what it means to live an ethical life. The foundations of an answer lie in a reconstruction of our sense of community. The sense of ethics has always been, inescapably, a social sense. We have always needed the experience of living in a community to develop an understanding of what is right and wrong. All the important moral questions arise from trying to live in a social context, and it is only from a sense of mutual dependency that we learn to appreciate the force of mutual obligation. [6]

Ethics develop more easily in small communities where people can see the immediate implications of their actions. It stands to reason that in big cities, where as individuals we are anonymous in many settings, we do not feel the same moral links. So a sense of community is an important part of a sense of quality of life and maintaining it should be a prime consideration in all development.

Living an ethical life means having a quality approach to every aspect of life. Hawken argues that we are being moulded for corporate markets, not the future [7]. For example, the typical adult can recognise a thousand brand names and logos, but fewer than ten local plants, yet understanding the process of biology is essential to our survival.

Let me emphasise what I mean by a systems approach to quality of life, ethics and community advantage, by describing to you one of the most beautiful small towns on earth. Perched halfway up a mountainside it overlooks the vast expanse of a river valley. Pine forests back it and sandstone canyons of gorgeous colour surround it. It has a delightful climate, a highly educated populace, nice housing, good public education and other public facilities. Yet, for all its apparent lifestyle benefits nothing would induce me to live in Los Alamos, New Mexico because it is a town in the business of manufacturing nuclear weapons of mass destruction. It is also a town in which to discuss the ethical issues relating to this is generally considered impolite [8].

Access

Most mornings I waken to the sound of kookaburras laughing. You will assume, therefore, that I live in a fairly rural environment. Kookaburras evoke the Australian bush. It is one of the contradictions alluded to by Mark Twain that, although Australia is a highly urbanised country, we have always imagined that the essence of what it is, is rural. It was the kookaburra's laugh that echoed through darkened cinemas at the beginning of newsreels which reinforced this idea to audiences who predominantly lived in cities and large regional centres. The newsreel kookaburra laughs no more but his descendant laughs in digitised form. When Apple executives in California want to demonstrate the power of electronic networks they hook into a data base at the National Botanic Gardens in Canberra, and a kookaburra's laughter rings through the boardrooms of Silicon Valley.

Linking to the global network through the Internet ended forever Australia's isolation from the rest of the world. But just as our population is clustered on the coast, so it would seem are our Internet users.

There has been a great deal of discussion of the Internet in the media in recent months. Much of it has been focussed on the so-called Yellow Brick Highway, the electronic superhighway. Electronic highways, though not the superhighways of the future, already exist. The vision of an international information superhighway is one that is shared by many in the information community. This Yellow Brick Highway would carry all forms of human communication that can be reduced to electronic form, from written messages (electronic mail) to interactive television. It would replace telephones, fax machines, and other communication services.

The superhighway is not just another technology-driven vision. The concept of transfering information electronically was conceived well over a century ago. Alexander William Bell, the inventor of the telephone, designed the Photophone - a device that could transmit information by light. The Photophone worked in a clear line of sight, so of course the signal was obscured by weather and smoke. It took the invention of laser light (1960) and fibre optic cable (1975) to make Bell's dream a reality.

Basically, the Internet is not a planned, cohesive network but rather a network of autonomous networks, which has been largely the domain of universities and research institutions. The Internet is also a chaotic cornucopia of information. You can plunge into cyberspace, forging deeper and deeper and forget how you arrived and how to get out. In the words of a columnist in the New York Times:

Information exists on Internet, but one is likely to hear a giant sucking sound as the Internet user is drawn ever deeper into the network in search of it [9]

Australian access to the Internet is via the Australian Academic and Research Network (AARNet). Tertiary Institutions, government departments, both Federal and State, CSIRO and sources of major online research resources such as the National Library are entitled to membership of AARNet. The Australian Vice Chancellors' Committee manages AARNet. It has had a policy of restricting membership to organisations involved mainly in research, but these restrictions are being eased. Indeed Geoff Huston, AARNet Manager and Chair of the Internet International Planning Group, has a clear vision of a future in which the Internet will be accessible to all Australians, as ubiquitous as the telephone.

Dennis Griffith of the Northern Territory Department of Education has advanced considerably the work on the measurement of accessibility to services with his development of the Griffith Ser vice Access Frame. While important in this model, geographical location is not the sole determinant of relative access status, as the model includes an index of Economic Resources (a standard ABS derivation). The underlying assumptions to the GSAF are

  • there is a direct relationship between the level of service available and the population size of the centre
  • access to services is dependent upon the distance between the location of the client population and point of service; and
  • access to services is dependent on the economic power of the community to meet the costs of overcoming distance [10]

The deregulation of the Australian telecommunications industry will be a two edged sword for remote communities. Profit will be the watchword in the battle to win the right to deliver perso nal communications services to the nations home's, including cable television, infotainment, and many other interactive computer-based services such as banking, bill paying and shopping. Already there are suggestions that cross- subsidisation will cease and thus ordinary phone services will cost much more in the bush. There is a rush to install fibre-optic cables in the suburbs of Melbourne and Sydney while rural centres struggle along without even ISDN lines. Without access to fibre-optic networks or, at worst ISDN, the range and format of information available to rural communities through the computer networks will be limited and the cost of access considerable.

We are also in danger of confusing mediaspace with cyberspace. Mediaspace is more encompassing, if for no other reason that we have been using electronic media for a long time now. Mediaspace is a passive medium, merely communicating signals from A to B. When you are in mediaspace, for example, using the telephone, you're simply talking to another person, using a seemingly passive communication tool. On the Internet, on the other hand, you' re clearly entering shared space. Thus, in cyberspace, it is you who enters the computer's realm, while in mediaspace the technology becomes ubiquitous and invisible, and it is more of a case of technology entering into our realm. This is why cyberspace w ill evolve into virtual reality, while mediaspace will evolve into 'augmented reality'. In augmented reality computers disappear into the physical surrounding, which becomes enhanced by embedded intelligence [11].

Access to information will be critical to the survival of rural communities, and if those communities do not ensure that this access is affordable they will be seriously disadvantaged. In t he coming battle for control of the marketplace there is a danger that, for rural communities, mediaspace will win.

Democracy

Access to information and the opportunities it brings can be the way to give the country the edge over the city. Taking a community approach will ensure that the venture is affordable, successful and democratic.

The New England town meeting is the most democratic form of local government, a form which has grown out of a real sense of community. As towns get bigger, people become more disenfranchise d. Smaller towns have an advantage in that local politicians and municipal employees are more accessible to the populace, though one rarely sees this point made in publicity aimed at attracting new businesses and residents. But like their counterparts in larger centres, they often have to depend on the media to get information to the residents. I do not need to outline the hazards thereof, nor the expense of the alternative: paid time on electronic media, paid advertisements in print media or direct mailings.

Bill Clinton now publishes his media releases electronically so messages from the White House can be accessed via Internet. The information is conveyed without commentary and without editing. Both he and the Vice-President can be e-mailed direct [12]. When you email them an autoresponder immediately sends an acknowledgment of receipt along with some useful information about the state of development of the White House System, how e-mail is dealt with, and information about accessing White House information sources. Can you imagine how much time and money is being saved by elimination of paper-shuffling and stationery and postage costs alone. Any local authority adopting a similar system would therefore be able to offset such savings against the cost of the system.

The ability to eliminate the difference between here and there, to operate in an information world in which there is only here, allows people to have both a sense of th e world community and an enhanced capacity to act in the interest of that community. Green groups have realised that the Internet lets them think and act globally. Eight years ago, it took a Danish group eight months to organise worldwide protests over Indonesian destruction of rain forest. John Seed, of Lismore's Rainforest Information Centre, says that when the Malaysian government was accused in November 1993 of breaking an anti-logging blockade in Sarawak demonstrations were held outside Malaysian consulates in Australia and the United States the next day [13].

Resource sharing

Many organisations tend to look at their information resource vertically instead of horizontally, in an integrated fashion, and regard their information resources as a necessary expense, the cost of doing business, rather than as a capitalised asset.

One approach to reducing the expense of delivering library services has been resource-sharing. The movement to create larger units of service rests fundamentally on two claims. The first is that it is more cost effective. The second is that, through resource sharing and cooperation, better service can be provided to the community. Resource sharing largely depends on formal relationships for borrowing books. Such networks are a variant form of the "larger unit of service" concept [14].

The theory of the larger unit of service has its foundation in three unproven assumptions:

  • that many valuable services requiring special training and education can only be provided by a library with resources of sufficient size to provide staff with specialised expertise.
  • that no individual library can possibly acquire the collections necessary to meet adequately the demand that exists in its community; and
  • that economies of scale apply in libraries.

The first assumption is easy to dismiss. Multi-skilled staff can provide the full range of services. To the third we can respond that there are also diseconomies of scale, as well as economy of variety.

Let us consider in more detail, the second assumption, that no library can possible hope to meet the needs of its own clients. It is true that there is no library in Australia that is sufficiently large to meet all the needs of its users. However, if a library has its collection development policy right, it will be seeking to ensure that its collection will meet some reasonably large percentage of demand, particularly for subject requests. For the bulk of all requests from its users, it should not be assumed that a library cannot be independent and meet the needs of its user population.

In public libraries, the research reported confirms what observation suggests. If a library does not have what is needed by a user, few are willing to wait for delivery from another source. The great majority of patrons never use any library other than the one closest to their home, no matter what its size.

Demand for convenience

Library users stubbornly insist on convenient access to books. Reflection on what we know about human nature, and observation of service trends in business, should confirm that convenience is becoming more rather than less important to customers, whether they be of libraries or any other type of service or business. In fact, the thrust of business change in this country has been to further this convenience-seeking behaviour.

The principal characteristic common to all manifestations of the larger unit of service concept is inconvenience. Patrons are asked either to go further to a better facility or to accept books that they have not been able to examine after a delay of varying duration.

What people want, however, is immediate access to a wider choice of books among which to browse. Immediate access involves two things - that the library is geographically accessible and that the books are on the shelves of the library. Therefore the expected level of use should not be a factor in either the quality of the collection or in the decision to serve a certain area. In any branch system there should not be a great imbalance in collection size anywhere in the system, and the placement of these libraries should be decided almost entirely on the distance factor and without any regard for the potential of some larger collection, remotely located, to meet any collection deficiencies.

The availability of the Internet has made possible the concept of the virtual or networked library, a generic library which has no defined boundaries, no administration, no staff, and no budget. The virtual library is one where the user has the illusion of access to a much larger collection of information than is really present, immediately or simultaneously [15].The virtual or Internet library belongs to nobody, rather it belongs to everybody. Nobody is in charge, and it is impossible to budget what cannot be defined. No group or organisation can control this virtual library, but any group can affect the Internet library by contributing or withholding influence or access. We must therefore view the Internet library from a perspective of influence rather than control.

This virtual library, however, must not be seen as a replacement for the paper library, but as an opportunity to enhance it so that the library holds a collection which is

...an accumulation of information-bearing objects - printed, aural, graphic, digital - housed within the physical library, and also indices, abstracts and catalogs through which, using electronic channels, the library user has access to pre-identified resources held by other libraries and information providers [16].

Competitiveness

Competitive advantage comes from not only having timely and informed knowledge about your environment, but understanding the implication or actions that are necessary as a consequence of this knowledge. Having the right information at the right time is often the difference between success and failure. In today's globally competitive marketplace, for an organisation or a community to succeed, it needs to act more intelligently with its environment.

Competitive intelligence is all about knowledge and concerns an organisation's market competitiveness. It is the ethical and legal gathering, evaluation and interpretation of information, based on data located in the public arena and communicated to an organisation's management, to allow for informed, strategic choices concerning the organisation's future. It is the capturing and processing of information flows, within an environment, that will play a major role in an organisation's or community's ability to develop a sustainable competitive advantage.

Part of the competitive edge is your efficiency or productivity. Utilising electronic communications networks to allow citizens to communicate with politicians, with bureaucrats, with each other, to gain access to community and other information, can provide equity of access to and distribution of information at a fraction of the cost of paper- based systems.

Access to better library and information services has benefits which contribute to the competitive edge of a community. These include higher productivity in libraries - better return on investment in resources, buildings, equipment and staff; increased information for decision-making; and increased capacity of the community to attract and hold businesses because competitive intelligence will be accessible to rural entities and overall the community will be better able to compete on quality of life issues with large cities.

While individual libraries have recognised the potential of modern advances in information storage, retrieval, communications and copying to locate original documents and transmit copies in a timely and efficient manner quick automatic dialling, high speed, no usage charges other than the annual connection fees and the ability to reach anywhere in the world. Imagine also that this tool enables those residents to do unlimited online searches of international academic and research libraries, exchange files of documents, and access the views and advice of the masses through news discussion groups.

Imagine that the gateway to all this is a community information system which uses an electronic city model and provides two-way communication with local government officials. Registered use rs log in and can access services with titles like Administration Building, Business and Industrial Park, School, Animal Hospital, Hospital, Courthouse, Television Station, Courthouse and Library and well as being able to access the Internet. Guests can l ogin and read local community information. In one fell swoop you have given your residents access to the world while you have emphasised their sense of their local community.

Imagine the local government authority or other government department being able to survey the residents quickly, cheaply, and electronically. Electronic questionnaires have been found to b e extremely useful and accurate. Researchers in the corporate world have discovered that people respond more honestly to questionnaire in electronic format, possibly because of the perceived anonymity of the computer. [17]

Imagine that all this costs something in the order of $10 per person per year, of which a large proportion is returned to the community in savings in the administration of the community.

Imagine now that this community information system is coordinated by people knowledgable about navigating information (i.e. skilled librarians), so that every resident can take advantage of expert liaison between himself and the world's burgeoning store of information and, if desired, can have those skilled knowledge navigators obtain needed information on his or her behalf or, alternatively, assist him or her to develop information discove ry skills.

Traditionally libraries have been defined by their clientele. Most of us understand, more or less, the difference between school libraries, university libraries, public libraries and the li braries in government departments and corporations.

Joint use public-school libraries have been one approach to meeting the needs of sectors of small communities which could not sustain viable dedicated libraries. It is my prediction that th ey will become increasingly common in communities which currently have neither. The Minister for Education in Queensland is committed in principle to joint use libraries and I have been proposing a proactive approach to their development. But I believe th at we could go further and take a collaborative approach to delivering the library and information services provided by State and Commonwealth Departments, by education and by local authorities from one site in rural communities. That site could also inco rporate a telecentre.

The Department of Primary Industries and Energy (DPIE) has provided assistance to interested community groups in rural Australia to establish a telecentre. Telecentres are locally controlle d and locally staffed computer information centres designed to support the economic, social, educational and training opportunities of rural communities through better access to telecommunications and information technologies.

History has demonstrated that only government actions can create equitable distributions of information resources. To achieve this the initiative will have to come from the rural communitie s.

As I've already described, Australia's access to the Internet is via AARNet. The preferred method of connection to AARNet is via a leased line direct to the relevant AARNet regional hub. AA RNet regional hubs are located in each Australian state and territory capital city. Where a link to the regional hub is impractical a link to a local AARNet AVCC member or CSIRO site may be considered by AARNet. However, as the Affiliate Member would then be sharing common capacity with the host AARNet member, this method of link may not be possible in all cases. And many towns do not have a local higher education campus or CSIRO site. It is imperative therefore that local government lobbies for fibre-opt ic connections and for coordination of access.

There are a number of opportunities which may be used to support the case for integrated services.

The report of the Task Force on Regional Development (Kelty Report) has recommended that the Government should explore ways in which public libraries can have cheaper access to on-line information [18] .

There is also a climate of regionalisation, with various government departments, including all Queensland state government department, focusing central offices on policy issues and increasing the service delivery functions of regional offices. But, as Peter Wilenski has pointed out, regionalisation itself does not guarantee participation.

At worst, regionalisation can simply amount to the development of mini-bureaucracies within a local context, devoid of community participation [19] and bureaucrats are often concerned that regional offices do not become completely autonomous and co-opted by their region, a phenomenon sometimes referred to as going "feral" [20].

Nonetheless, regionalisation of state and commonwealth government information and other services will continue because of political commitment.

The Department of Education in Queensland, for example, favours a regionalised organisation capable of responding to differences in clients' needs and resources over a centralised system which emphasises uniformity of resources. To achieve equity, or fairness, higher staff/student ratios at small remote schools have to be coupled with the application of communication technology. Projects such as telelearning, where students at remote school s "join" classes at larger schools, and the use of access to networked information are underway. The Department is at the moment running two studies of the use of the Internet to support effective learning and teaching and is spending millions of dollars each year to ensure that every school child in Queensland has access to a computer at school. What is missing is statewide access to the high speed networks. This deficiency limits the capacity of schools in more isolated communities to fully exploit the potential of networked electronic information sources for educational purposes. Here is an opportunity for coordinated effort. Increased educational opportunities within a region would both meet the Department's goals and improve the quality of life and thus the competitive edge of that region.

Conclusion

Even after the passage of a century Mark Twain's view of Australia still holds true, and will continue to hold true as long as Australia hangs on to one of its great hidden resources, the A ustralian "bushie".

I came across an intriguing definition of the word idiot a few months ago. In a travel article, author Jacqueline Swartz remarks: "Solitude is for idiots: the ancient Greek word idios means private, outside society." [21]  No one who has lived in a rural environment in any country can fail to be aware of the various not very flattering epithets that have been applied since time immemorial to country folk by city-dwellers - country bum pkin, local yokel, peasant, hayseed, to name but a few. The underlying definition of all of these is someone who knows little about the world and is relatively unsophisticated. In other words, someone who is regarded by his or her urban neighbours to be little more than an idiot.

Despite this less than flattering press, the reason that I refer to the Australian bushie as one of our great hidden resources has less to do with my own small town background than it has to the fact that a real bushie is someone who is not too sure about the meaning of the word impossible. Real bushies address all problems with a mix of faith and improvisation that helps them overcome the most impossible odds.

Developing integrated library and information services which provide access to the global community while still emphasising, supporting and enhancing the sense of the local community struct ure, will require a deal of improvisation and a belief in the importance of the community as a definable entity. It will also require enough faith for communities which are essentially competing with each other to work together to lobby other levels of government in order to ensure that the infrastructure required to enable a community based integrated solution to information isolation is speedily put into place.

References

  1.        quoted  in Thoeming, Peter  The most beautiful lies  Smart  woman, October/November 1993 pp 91-96, p 91
  2. Nirenberg,  John  The  living organization:  transforming teams into workplace communities. San Diego, Pfeiffer 1993 p 133
  3. quoted  in  McNulty,  Robert  The  economics  of  amenity  Meanjin 47(4) Summer 1988 pp 615-624
  4. Sculley, J Odyssey London, Fontana 1987 p 45
  5. quoted  in  Neville, Richard Creative edge:  capitalism's secret plan The Hames report 2(6) February 1994 pp 61-62
  6. Mackay, Hugh. Point of view: heeding the wisdom of the elders. The Hames Report 2(6) February 1994 pp 62-63
  7. quoted  in  Neville, Richard Creative edge: capitalism's  secret plan. The Hames report 2(6) February 1994 pp 61-62
  8. Peck,  M  Scott,  A  world waiting to be  born: civility rediscovered New York, Bantam, 1993 pp 231-232
  9. Lewish, Peter H. Business Section 3. New York Times December 12 1993 p 7
  10.        Griffith, D A Quantifying access to services in  remote and  rural Australia in Education, equity and the crisis in  the rural
           community
    ed J M R Cameron and D A Griffith
    Proceedings  of the Rural Education Research  Association Conference, Alice
           Springs 1992
  11.        Bauwens, Michael Cyberspace, virtualisation, and the role of  cybrarians  Antwerp,  Information   Department  BP Nutrition
           January 1994
  12. President@WhiteHouse.gov and Vice-President@WhiteHouse.gov
  13. Button, James Around the world in eighty seconds Time, December 13 1993 pp 52-59 p 56
  14.        Ballard, Thomas H The failure of resource sharing in public libraries and alternative strategies for service Chicago, American
           Library Association 1986 p 5
  15.        Harley, A J Towards the virtual library in The nationwide provision and use of information Sheffield, Aslib ISS LA Joint
           Conference 15-19 September 1990 pp 163-166
  16. Ghikas, Mary W Collection management in the twenty-first century Journal of library administration 11(1/2) pp 119-135
  17. Sproulle, Lee and Kiesler, Sara Computers, networks and work Scientific American 265(3) 1991 pp 84-91
  18. Developing Australia: a regional perspective Canberra, AGPS 1993
  19. Wilenski, P Public power and public administration Sydney, Hale and Iremonger 1986.
  20.        Sargent, John P Regionalism & economic development:  propping up or strategic choice?  - II: a state government  perspective.
          
    Canberra bulletin of public administration
    no 70 October 1992 pp 98-101
  21. Swartz, Jacqueline Solitude is for idiots Saturday night  September 1990 p 73