![]() home > publishing > alj > 52.1 > full.text > A decade of recordkeeping education at Curtin University of Technology: flux and flexibility |
|||
The Australian Library JournalA decade of recordkeeping education at Curtin University of Technology: flux and flexibilityMargaret PemberManuscript received May 2002 This is a refereed article This study reports on the findings of a survey of graduates from both courses for the years 1992-2000. The findings indicate that the typical graduate is likely to be female (sixty-eight per cent), have little prior experience in the field (56.4 per cent), and be aged between 21-30 years (30.9 per cent). She will prefer full-time (58.2 per cent), on-campus (58.2 per cent) modes of study. The first position after graduation is likely to be permanent (seventy-two per cent) or of a continuing contract nature (twenty-four per cent), be gained through networking contacts (46.9 per cent) or advertisement (26.5 per cent). Starting salary is likely to be in the $30 000 to $40 000 range (forty-nine per cent) and current salary in the $40 000 to $50 000 range (34.7 per cent) or $50 000+ range (28.6 per cent). The major difference between graduates is that those from the undergraduate degree are far more likely to have prior experience in the field and are completing the degree in order to upgrade knowledge and skills and enhance career prospects, whereas the graduate diploma students are more usually doing the course in order to facilitate a career change or re-entry to the workforce.[Comments extracted from open-ended questions in the survey instrument] With only one graduate unemployed and seeking work (an undergraduate), the employment rate is ninety-eight per cent. Expanding the career horizonDick Harrington, president and chief executive officer of the Thomson Corporation, a leading global e-information and solutions company, stated in his keynote speech at a recent leadership forum for senior business information leaders from Europe, North America and the Asia-Pacific, that 'we need to get the right information to the right people at the right time with the right applications software, to enable clients to make the right decisions'.[1] Throughout his presentation Harrington emphasised that if corporations did not appreciate the value of information and the timeliness with which it needed to be disseminated throughout the organisation, they would be unlikely to survive in the knowledge economy. He also stressed that pro-active management of the information/intellectual assets of the organisation is crucial to competitive advantage and corporate success, even survival, and should be a basic component of corporate strategic planning. Jim Shepherd[2] used very similar words at a Records Management Association of Australia conference back in the 80s: '... the right information, in the right order, at the right place, in the hands of the correct people, at the lowest possible cost...' Shepherd had started expressing similar sentiments in the 1970s when a group from the Brisbane City Council realised the importance of setting goals and objectives for records management and information management in the organisational context. Jim Shepherd and his team used this mantra across all levels of records management training from the town clerk down to junior officers and subsequently in many conference and seminar presentations across Australia. Those in education and training have long been teaching students of records and information management at all levels in TAFE and universities the importance of this targeted delivery of information and the need for fundamental records management standards, policies, procedures and processes to underpin successful management and delivery. Basic aims for records management in the policy documentation of many organisations still often rely on this concept developed by Jim Shepherd so long ago. Managing information as an asset is not new either! Back in the 1980s Burk, Horton, and Marchand, among others,[3] did a lot a work in the area of information resource management. They emphasised the need for information to play a strategic, not simply a support role, in the organisation, and for this to become possible organisational information resources needed to be carefully mapped: The discovery process will illuminate problems and opportunities related to current information management practices and policies. For example it will indicate your relative strengths and weaknesses with respect to information quality, accessibility, performance, use and effectiveness; highlight real dollar costs and waste .... and provide a comprehensive overview of its [the organisation's] information sources, services and systems... [4] The current 'hype' about knowledge management is in part a case of changing terminology and 'discovery' by a new generation of information professionals which has embraced the concept with skill and enthusiasm and carried it forward into another arena. Today we talk of mobilising knowledge, the value of intellectual assets, information capital, 'communities of practice', with a focus on harvesting the tacit or implicit knowledge of the organisation and adding it to explicit organisational knowledge. A far greater focus on sharing and exchange of information is evident across successful organisations. Whether this process is referred to as information resource management or knowledge management, the process still needs to be grounded on basic principles for the 'best practice' management of recorded information such as those espoused in AS 4390 [5] and ISO 15489 [6]. Logical progression integrates these basics into the bigger picture of organisational culture and structure with carefully formulated strategic objectives, the identified needs of client groups, the need to manage effectively the information assets and intellectual capital in a dynamic but specific, often global, environment and juridical context. The challenge is great, not one for the faint-hearted, but certainly an opportunity for pro-active information professionals.[7] Recordkeeping professionals need to consider how much longer the traditional role of records manager is likely to exist. In many organisations the role has already disappeared! In the quest for knowledge management, many organisations bypass the records section and opportunities are grasped by library or information technology staff. In still others, records personnel are grabbing the opportunities offered with both hands and moving into new and exciting, often challenging and confronting spheres of information management. Often these opportunities are disguised under new job titles such as knowledge manager or chief knowledge officer, and frequently these are new positions in the organisation with salaries several levels above the current senior records management or library positions. When position descriptions are examined, however, they may reflect the role many records managers or special librarians already perform. Opportunities are emerging and practitioners need to continue to develop professionally in order to make the most of these opportunities. To stand still is a sure road to marginalisation. Core skills and competenciesWhat are the core skills and competencies required of today's and tomorrow's record, information and knowledge managers? What is the profile of the 'ideal' professional? A list of essential criteria extracted largely from job advertisements in The West Australian (1996-2000), duty statements from Western Australian Public Service position descriptions, and the recordkeeping competency standards [8], includes:
It appears from the job advertisements and position descriptions surveyed that these skills and competencies should be supported by at least two to three years relevant experience, a basic 'apprenticeship' at the coalface. Curtin University case studyTertiary institutions aim to build these core skills and the underlying knowledge base into their curricula. Just how well Curtin University does this will be investigated in a subsequent phase of the study. The initial phase of the study focussed on the students, their mode of study and career progression since graduation. The undergraduate degree, the Bachelor of Applied Science (Records Management), began in 1990 and the first intake of students completed their studies in November 1992. The graduate program began as two separate graduate diplomas in records management and archives in 1994. These were amalgamated into a single qualification, the Graduate Diploma in Records Management and Archives, in 1995. Since that time there has been a steady stream of graduates from both courses. The courses themselves have changed considerably over time. Initially the undergraduate course had a common first year with librarianship students. This was gradually reduced to common classes for the more generic information units and a greater emphasis on information technology, with students being required to do at least a four-unit minor (and preferably an eight-unit major) in information systems. Further course changes have recently been introduced which will produce graduates able to work across the library, records and archives fields. At the graduate level the course is moving to a modular approach, whereby students can gain a four-unit core module in information management (certificate), then add another four-unit module in a specific area (qualification becomes a graduate diploma), and a further four-unit module to complete a masters degree (by coursework). These modules or clusters can be in the areas of records management, archives, knowledge management, electronic document management, internet studies, library studies, and so on. Practitioners can build on existing qualifications. For example, someone with a graduate diploma can simply complete another four-unit module or cluster to upgrade his or her qualifications to a masters degree by coursework. The traditional research masters still exists for those interested in in-depth research, while the new coursework masters provides the opportunity to upskill in areas of professional need. All courses can be undertaken either full-time or part-time, and are offered by either internal or external (distance education and/or on-line) study.
The survey In order to encourage recipients to be as candid as possible the respondents were not required to identify themselves and questionnaires were not numbered or marked in any way. However, provision was made for the supply of contact details, should the respondents be willing and available for further in-depth research. Sixty-nine per cent of respondents supplied their contact details (thirty-eight out of fifty-five). It is intended that these graduates will form the nucleus of a focus group in a further phase of the research. The questionnaire was divided into four sections. The first section was to determine the nature of the course studied, the second the characteristics of the student cohort, the third their reasons for embarking on a study program in records/archives, and lastly a section on employment history since graduation. Course
Table 1: Recordkeeping course completed by respondents, 1992-2000 The response to this question reflects the general enrolment pattern of students in the undergraduate (43.9 per cent) and graduate diploma (56.1 per cent) courses over the period the courses have been available. Mode of study
Table 2: Full-time/part-time choices of recordkeeping graduates, 1992-2000 At both undergraduate and graduate level full-time study is the preferred option of respondents; with 68.2 per cent of undergraduate students and 51.5 per cent of graduate students making this choice. When averaged across courses this full-time choice is made by 58.2% of students.
Table 3 Internal/external choices of recordkeeping graduates, 1992-2000 The internal mode of study is the preferred study option, especially at the graduate diploma level, with almost two-thirds (60.6 per cent) of completing students making this choice. The average for completing students across both courses is 58.2 per cent internal, 29.1 per cent external and 12.7 per cent of students combining internal and external modes to suit their particular needs. Gender
Table 4: Gender of recordkeeping graduates, 1992-2000 Overall there is very little difference in the gender balance between graduates of the undergraduate and graduate diploma courses; the ratio being approximately one third (thirty-two per cent) male to two-thirds female (sixty-eight per cent) across both courses. These figures represent all students completing the courses, not just those returning the questionnaire. Age
Table 5: Age of respondents enrolling in recordkeeping courses, 1992-2000 Maturity of students is reflected in the age table. Ages were gauged at the commencement of the study program. At the undergraduate level only three respondents (13.6 per cent) commenced the degree before they were twenty-one. The highest percentage commenced study in their 30s (45.5 per cent), followed by those in their 20s and 40s (both 18.2 per cent). At the graduate diploma level 39.4 per cent of completing students began their course of study in their 20s, followed by 36.4 per cent in their 40s, and 18.2 per cent in their 30s. When undergraduate figures are combined with graduate diploma figures the spread becomes more even with 30.9 per cent of students commencing study in their 20s, 29.1 per cent in their 30s and 29.1 per cent in their 40s. Only 5.5 per cent begin study in their 50s, and 5.5 per cent under 21. Prior experience
Table 6: Prior experience of recordkeeping graduates before commencement of study Quite a significant difference in recordkeeping experience prior to commencement of study is apparent between courses. 59.1 per cent of undergraduate students have prior experience in the field; whereas this is the case for only 33.3 per cent of graduate students. The average across courses is 43.6 per cent with prior experience and 56.4 per cent without. The nature of this experience covers the whole gamut of recordkeeping practice in the public and private sector from correspondence control and file management to appraisal and disposal and is evenly spread from those with less than two years experience to those with more than fifteen years experience. Employment history
Table 7: Employment history of recordkeeping graduates, 1992-2000 **Three graduates are currently on maternity leave so have not been included in the figures. Two were in full-time employment until they took extended maternity leave; the other took leave immediately after graduation. Two other graduates have not yet sought employment in the field. The employment pattern across both courses is quite similar. When figures are combined across courses the majority of graduates (ninety-six per cent) have been in continuous or almost continuous employment since graduation (twenty-four per cent of these are in contract or casual employment of a continuing nature). Four graduates noted initial problems on graduation but are now in permanent employment. Only one graduate is reported as 'unemployed, seeking work' (two per cent) and one reported 'long periods of unemployment (two per cent). It should be noted that these figures include a number of students who graduated at the end of 2000, a matter of months after the survey was distributed, and all were recorded as employed. It appears that getting that first job is not a major problem, although it may initially be of a contract nature rather than a permanent position. Annual salary level of first recordkeeping position after graduation
Table 8: Annual salary level of first recordkeeping position The first records position after graduation for almost half (forty-nine per cent) of the graduates of either course is in the $30 00 to $40 000 range. 39.3 per cent begin in the $20 00 to $30 000 range, 9.8 per cent in the $40 000 to $50 000 range, and 1.9 per cent over $50 000. Less undergraduate than graduate diploma level students start in the $20 000 to $30 000 range; this may be a result of the higher percentage with prior experience at the undergraduate level and needs further investigation to prove or disprove. Current annual recordkeeping salary level
Table 9: Current annual salary levels of recordkeeping graduates Given that the figures include graduates from 1992 to 2000, the levels are purely indicative. For example, three graduate diploma students employed in the $20 000 to $30 000 range only graduated at the end of 2000 so it is their starting as well as their current salary. Further work will cross-tabulate years of experience with salary level. Three graduates are currently on maternity leave so have not been included in the figures. Two were in full-time employment ($40 000 to $50 000 level) until they took extended maternity leave; the other has yet to obtain her first employment in the field. Two other graduates have not yet applied for employment in the field. Overall figures indicate that 10.2 per cent of graduates are employed in the $20 000 to $30 000 range, 26.5 per cent in the $30 000 to $40 000 range, 34.7 per cent in the $40 000 to $50 000 range, and 28.6 per cent over $50 000. Method of gaining first recordkeeping position
Table 10: Method of gaining first recordkeeping position, graduates 1992-2000 *Again those not in employment for various reasons such as maternity leave have not been included in the calculations. At the undergraduate level a third of graduates obtained their first recordkeeping position through advertisement (only one through public service notices). Networking contacts accounted for another third of first appointments; and a further 23.9 per cent remained with the same employer. 9.5 per cent gained employment through a specialist information related employment agency. At the graduate diploma level over half (57.1 per cent) cited networking of some kind as the catalyst for employment (particularly networking with professional association (RMAA and ASA) contacts, personal contacts and university staff.) Advertisements accounted for 21.4 per cent of first appointments, employment through agencies 14.3 per cent, and those remaining with the same employers accounted for 7.2 per cent. When figures are combined for undergraduate and graduate diploma courses the predominant mode of finding employment is networking at 46.9 per cent, followed by advertisement at 26.5 per cent. 14.3 per cent remained with the same employer probably indicating some level of support on the part of the employer for the studies undertaken. Employment agencies play a significant role at 12.3 per cent. Profiles of graduatesFrom the data collected the typical graduate of the undergraduate course is likely to be female (67.5 per cent), have prior experience in the field (59.1 per cent), and be aged between thirty-one and forty years at the commencement of the course (45.5 per cent). She will prefer full-time (68.2 per cent), on-campus (54.5 per cent) modes of study. The first position after graduation is likely to be permanent (77.3 per cent), or of a continuing contract nature (18.2 per cent). First recordkeeping positions are usually gained through a newspaper advertisement (33.3 per cent) or networking contacts (33.3 per cent), although a significant number remain with the same employer (23.9 per cent). Starting salary is likely to be in the $30 000 to $40 000 range (47.7 per cent) and current salary in the $50 000+ range (42.9 per cent).[Further work will cross-tabulate salary scales to years of experience since graduation.] The typical graduate of the graduate diploma course is likely to be female (68.5 per cent), have no prior experience (66.7 per cent), and be aged between twenty-one and thirty years (39.4 per cent) or forty-one to fifty years (36.4 per cent) at commencement of study. She will prefer full-time (51.5 per cent), on-campus (60.6 per cent) modes of study. The first position after graduation is likely to be permanent (67.9 per cent) or of a continuing contract nature (28.5 per cent), and be gained through networking contacts (57.1 per cent). Starting salary is likely to be in the $30 000 to $40 000 range (50 per cent) and current salary in the $40 000 to $50 000 range (39.3 per cent). The typical graduate across both courses is likely to be female (68 per cent), have little prior experience in the field (56.4 per cent), and be aged between twenty-one and thirty years (30.9 per cent). She will prefer full-time (58.2 per cent), on-campus (58.2 per cent) modes of study. The first position after graduation is likely to be permanent (72 per cent) or of a continuing contract nature (24 per cent), be gained through networking contacts (46.9 per cent) or advertisement (26.5 per cent). Starting salary is likely to be in the $30 000 to $40 000 range (49 per cent) and current salary in the $40 000 to $50 000 range (34.7 per cent) or $50 000+ range (28.6 per cent). The major difference between graduates is that those from the undergraduate degree are far more likely to have prior experience in the field and are completing the degree in order to upgrade knowledge and skills and enhance career prospects, whereas the graduate diploma students are more usually doing the course in order to facilitate a career change or re-entry to the workforce after childraising is complete.[Comments extracted from open-ended questions in the survey instrument.] With only one graduate unemployed and seeking work (an undergraduate), the employment rate is ninety-eight per cent (students unavailable for employment, for example those on maternity leave, are not included in these figures). Graduate commentsGraduates were given the opportunity to comment on various aspects of the course and the educational experience. Open-ended responses to positive aspects of the course include comments such as 'a good balance between technical and theoretical', 'high degree of professionalism and enthusiasm amongst staff', 'information systems units', 'practica', 'case studies', 'site visits', 'workplace projects', 'group work', 'development of mentoring relationships', and 'comprehensive feedback and support'. Positive outcomes reported include 'development of personal and professional confidence', 'feelings of self-fulfilment', 'empowerment', 'development of networking contacts', 'formal recognition of the skills acquired through practical experience', 'professional recognition', 'employment at managerial level', 'knowledge of the higher level strategic requirements and ramifications of records management', 'continuous employment and good career prospects'. Suggestions for improving the course include comments such as 'less focus on library studies', 'replacement of some of the library units with more records and archives units', 'closer connection to the workplace for some lecturers', 'greater use of tutors still in the workplace', 'stronger management focus', 'even greater focus on technology', 'more hands-on work experience', and 'improved access to some lecturers'. A number of graduates of the graduate diploma courses also noted that it would almost impossible to include anything extra in the course given the time constraints of the one-year course. Despite these suggestions for improvement, the majority of students were very positive about the nature of the course and the outcomes, particularly in the area of employment prospects and were very pleased they had completed the course (96 per cent). Both positive and negative aspects of the feedback have implications for educators and will need to be investigated more fully through focus groups and a thorough mapping of course content consistent with identified competencies and standards and the perceived needs and direction of the industry. Further researchAlison Jago,[12] writing in 1993 about the situation in the United Kingdom, bemoaned the dearth of suitable applicants when recruiting information staff. Jago noted that despite job losses due to company streamlining, the so called 'leaner and meaner' approach, good staff were extremely difficult to find. She also noted that most job seekers in the field were already in work and wanted to change for positive reasons. To be tempting, the job offered had to satisfy some identified professional need, such as offering broader experience or additional skills. Job satisfaction and personal development were more important than higher salaries as prime motivators for job change. This kind of applicant was generally 'prepared to wait until the right job came along' (1993: 31). Those applicants seeking job changes for negative reasons were more likely to accept positions offered as an escape mechanism from their current employment. Has anything changed since Jago did this study? Is it any different in Australia? The cry is often heard 'we just can't get the staff we need to fill the job vacancies we have' or that when positions are advertised suitable applicants are not available and they have to be re-advertised or 'less than optimum' appointments made. This anecdotal evidence will need to be investigated fully in a future phase of the study. ConclusionThe nature of recordkeeping has changed forever in this exciting, dynamic, highly technical, more litigious, more competitive global environment. For many organisations this has meant the loss of the traditional records manager, even the whole records section as we knew it. Few would deny that the profession has moved from one based largely on a passive centralised reception of paper-based documents to one that abounds with exciting, albeit challenging, possibilities in a world of constantly evolving electronic documents. Emphasis has moved from the purely reactive management of hard-copy records to encompass the pro-active management of the electronic record, and for many, a far more active role in the provision of information services to one's client group. Theoretical and industry-driven developments mean that education and training for recordkeeping professionals need to encompass a wider range of knowledge and skills than ever before. New roles will demand new and constantly updated knowledge and skills. Unless recordkeeping practitioners continue to develop professionally to meet the demands of these new roles they risk losing leadership roles to other information professionals. It is estimated that it now takes only five years for current skill levels to become obsolete, so commitment to continuing professional development becomes critical, and something for which individuals should take responsibility.[13] Given the increasingly evident emphasis on standards and information and communications technology, graduates need to demonstrate 'hands-on' competence in a wide range of practical and technical skills in these areas to complement their understanding of the basic principles underlying information management theory. On top of these theoretical understandings and technical competencies, sought-after graduates exhibit a wide range of transferable workplace skills such as interpersonal or people skills, broad communication skills, self- and team- management skills, and intellectual skills. Ideally one needs to 'do time' at the coalface, basically an apprenticeship, where the theory learned can be put into practice. Some graduates (59.1 per cent at the undergraduate level) did this 'time' before they started study, others do it while they study, and still others do it after their study is complete. This 'hands-on' experience appears to give a high level of confidence as well as honing the practical and technical skills required in the workplace. Those who have theoretical knowledge backed with experience also seem to have greater credibility amongst peers and prospective employers.[14] The consolidation of fundamental recordkeeping skills through this basic 'apprenticeship' provides a good foundation on which to build the next level of competencies required for a successful career, those of management, and some practitioners then make the decision to develop these skills through further study in the management area. It is encouraging to note that students graduating from Curtin University recordkeeping courses are finding ready employment in the field, with ninety-eight per cent of respondents employed at the time of the study. Students were very open about their experiences and perceptions of the courses, and many made constructive suggestions for change. The overall satisfaction level of ninety-six per cent reflects a perceived correlation by the graduates between knowledge and skills acquired in the course and those required in the workplace. Curtin courses in recordkeeping and all aspects of information and library studies have changed considerably over the past decade and will continue to change to meet the needs of the profession and provide well-rounded programmes for aspiring information professionals. Endnotes 1. Harrington, D (2001) 11th European Business Information Conference (EBIC) in Rome, March 2001. Reported in TFPL Newsletter Spring 2001 p1. 2. Shepherd, J (June 2001) Personal communication. 3. Burk, C and Horton, F W (1988) Information resource management: a complete guide to discovering corporate information resources. Prentice Hall; Horton, FW (1979) Information resources management: concepts and cases. Cleveland, OH: Association for Systems Management; Marchand, DM and Horton, FW (1986) Infotrends: Profiting from your information resources. New York: Wiley, etc. 4. Burk, C and Horton, FW (1988) Information resource management: a complete guide to discovering corporate information resources. Prentice Hall, pp 4-5. 5. Standards Australia. (1996) Records management AS4390-1996. Homebush, NSW: SA. 6. International Standards Organization (2001) ISO 15489 Information and documentation - records management, (Parts 1 and 2), the international records management standard launched at Montreal in October 2001. 7. See the work of Southon, G, and Todd, R (2001) 'Library and information professionals and knowledge management: conceptions, challenges and conflicts', Australian Library Journal, 50(2); Todd, R.J, and Southon, G (2001) 'Educating for a knowledge management future: perceptions of library and information professionals', Australian Library Journal, 50 (4); Abell, A, and Oxbrow, N (2001) Competing with knowledge: the information profession in the knowledge management age. London: Library Association; Milne, P (2000) 'Information professionals and the knowledge-aware, intelligent organisation: skills for the future', Australian Library Journal, 49(2): 139-150. 8. Taken from Western Australian Public Service job descriptions and job advertisements in The West Australian over a 5-year period (1996-2000), and recordkeeping competency standards. 9. Standards Australia (1996) Records management AS4390-1996. Homebush, NSW: SA. 10. Business Services Training Australia Ltd (2000) Recordkeeping competency standards draft 3 October 2000: Training package. ANTA; and original version Archives and records competency standards, November 1997. Another useful tool is the Competency profile: information resources management specialists in archives, libraries and records management: A comprehensive cross-sectoral competency analysis. The Alliance of Libraries, Archives and Records Management (ALARM) in partnership with the Cultural Human Resources Council with the support of Human Resources Development Canada in April 1999 published this profile. 11. Genoni, P, Exon, M and Farrelly, K (2000) 'Graduate employment outcomes for qualifying library and records management courses at Curtin University of Technology', Australian Library Journal, 49(3): 245-258. 12. Jago, A (1993) 'Join the team! Recruiting for information professionals', Library Management, 14(1): 31-34. 13. Pember, M (1998) 'The rise of the 'new age' records management professional: records management education and training in Australia', Records Management Journal, 8(3): 63-76. 14. Comments based on anecdotal evidence. This is another thread that will be followed in subsequent research. Biographical information Margaret Pember has been an information studies lecturer in the School of Media and Information at Curtin University of Technology for the last seven years. She previously worked as the records manager/archivist for the City of Perth. Prior to that, she was involved in the Royal Commission into the Commercial Activities of Government and Other Matters. Margaret was made a Fellow of the RMAA (Records Management Association of Australia) in 1999 - this was a great honour as in the 30-year history of the Association, only six members had been awarded Fellowships. E-mail: margaret@biblio.curtin.edu.au |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|