Australian Library and Information Association
home > advocacy > alw > 2004 > LIW Forum outcomes
 

[ copyright | broadband | online filtering | government publications | library week | storytime | alia stars | aliaNEWS ]

2004 Library and Information Week Forum

'Down and loaded: the right information at the right time' Australian Library and Information Association

ALIA House Conference Room, 9-11 Napier Close, Deakin. ACT
Monday 24 May 2004
Convenor: Christine Mackenzie, ALIA past President

Contents


Introduction

The Australian Library and Information Association (ALIA) hosted 2004 Library and Information Week Forum to develop a collaborative framework to advance electronic networking initiatives and ideas for sharing resources, improving efficiencies, increasing access to public information and enhancing services provided by the library and information sector.

In planning the Forum the Association's Board of Directors considered that the Senate Inquiry into Libraries in the Online Environment report, submissions and evidence provided a valuable resource of data on the composition, achievements, activities and challenges for the library and information sector. In particular Recommendation 7 of the Report recommends that:

  1. the Australian government negotiate with telecommunications carriers to establish an 'e-rate' or discount rate for broadband access to public libraries and that, if negotiations are not successful, consider imposing a requirement on carriers under the Universal Service Obligation arrangement; and
  2. further funds be allocated under an expanded National Broadband Strategy for expanding broadband access in libraries.

This and related recommendations on digitisation, community networks and access to electronic information were the focus of the Forum.

The Forum brought together representatives from the library and information services sector, Australian government, Telstra, local government, and community networking research to discuss these recommendations in the context of current models, government programs, initiatives, and priorities within the sector, and to agree on actions to progress shared priorities and goals for the sector. The Association proposed that the Forum be the precursor of a national symposium in 2005 to further advance collaboration in e-community linked networking, broadband access and public access to electronic resources and services through libraries.

The Federal Minister for the Arts Senator the Hon Rod Kemp provided a Welcome and Library and Information Week message to open the Forum.

The program included presentations on models, programs and initiatives by VICNET, Telstra, Monash University Centre for Community Networking Research (CCNR), the Department of Communications, Information Technology and the Arts (DCITA) National Broadband Strategy, and the Australian Local Government Association (ALGA). Forum participants discussed and agreed on proposed strategies to make more information available easily and efficiently to more Australians.


top

Agreed Initiatives

National Broadband Strategy Implementation Group

Helen McLaren, Manager, Connectivity Strategy and Policy section, Department of Communications, IT and the Arts offered the opportunity for the sector to make a presentation to the National Broadband Strategy Implementation Group later in 2004. Currently there is an emphasis in the Broadband Strategy on the education and health sectors. The Forum agreed to take up this opportunity and to prepare a presentation that would recommend that the Strategy be pushed out beyond the initial focus on the education and health sectors to sectors such as the library and information services (LIS) sector which have infrastructures in place and an equally valid role in services delivery.

The Presentation (or Framework) is to be developed by ALIA, VICNET and CCNR, framing the concepts encapsulated in the issues outlined below; illustrating them with examples of models and initiatives that the sector is currently employing; outlining potential initiatives for the sector and proposing how and when these could be achieved working with broadband strategies. The Forum participants will sign off the draft presentation. It is proposed that it be presented for discussion at a session/workshop at ALIA 2004 Biennial Conference, 22-24 September 2004.

The presentation could also form the basis for a response from the sector to the Government's new Strategic Framework for the Information Economy which will identify key national priorities and strategies for the information economy over the next three years.

A further opportunity for the presentation is to submit the document to the Online Ministers Council, and in particular the Online Council Officials Group and its Integrated Transaction Reference Group (to be renamed National Services Framework Group).

Following the meeting Helen McLaren (DCITA) advised that dates have not been set beyond the next meeting of the NBSIG which is on 22-23 July in Canberra. Helen will advise of future dates after that. To be formally included on the agenda the Forum should provide DCITA with some information about the presentation and a paper (or power point slides) ahead of time. Peter Huta, DCITA, will send through further information on NBSIG meetings and other matters (eg announcements of community demand aggregation broker and of second round of CCIF and DABP) as it becomes available.

Action: ALIA will develop the project plan for the presentation to the National Broadband Strategy Implementation Group. The presentation will be prepared by ALIA, VICNET (David Feighan), CCRN (Don Schauder), with assistance from CASL Digital Issues Working Group, PLA (Lynne Makin), ALIA Public Libraries Reference Group, NLA (Warwick Cathro), ALGA (Rick Molony). Charu Sood and CAUL (Diane Costello) will provide comment on the draft.

The Framework to be developed is linked to the following initiatives identified and to be included in the project plan:

Peering arrangements

Work with the National broadband adviser (education) Peter Nissen to investigate opportunities for using peering arrangements to benefit access to information and infrastructure.

Broadband demand register and libraries

Investigate the feasibility of libraries being a focus point for establishing a demand register - especially in the urban fringe and rural and regional areas.

Mapping broadband availability

Investigate resources available to map library locations to broadband availability in building a services framework. Resources could include Telstra's facility, VICNET and other state library network providers, and Australian Libraries Gateway.

State government programs

Identify state based programs, document library and information services sector experiences and outcomes, and map these to enhance co-ordination of efforts and linkages with federal programs.


top

Issues to be developed

  • What is broadband? Libraries may need to introduce a matrix of what broad range of services are possible under what type of connection.

What e-rate model? Is there demand/aggregation. Develop a business case, utilise current models - eg VICNET and consortia participants. This may involve a tiered approach to ensure small, medium and large library data users get an equitable slice of the subsidy.

  • Models and links
  • Standardisation of metrics / benchmarking
  • Peering arrangements
  • Incorporating community information [civil society, Community Heritage Grants]
  • E-government information - engaging with community - libraries as facilitators
  • Utilising local government initiatives - opportunities and overlaps [state level partnerships, ALGA/ALIA - national and policy level]
  • Other networks - higher education, government - interoperability [digitisation, records, access, legal deposit]
  • Content generation, standards and metadata
  • Training - back/front end
  • Mainstreaming, sustainability

Through contacts for Australian Museums Online (AMOL) provided by Peter Huta (DCITA) ALIA will ascertain the current status of AMOL and its expansion to libraries and archives.


top


Summary of presentations

VICNET (David Feighan)

VICNET has conducted a project to map public libraries' online data usage, using data from metropolitan and rural library services that form part of VICNETS eCommunity network.

Outcomes of the project included:

  • Library services each use very different amounts of data to support their patrons and staff
  • Online data requirements appear to be driven by a complex set of factors such as bandwidth capacity, opening hours, number of terminals and the socio-economic profile of the user population. The most important influence on the volume of online data used appears to be the library's internet use policies and the resources the library has dedicated to supporting and maintaining these policies.
  • In the short term libraries may be able to manage their online data usage and slow the growth of their data overheads through tighter internet use policies (eg. blocking services such as data streaming or P2P file sharing); however such policies may not be sustainable in the long-term as online content becomes richer and more dynamic.
  • Strategic peering arrangements where data costs are removed between collaborating partners could have considerable impact on reducing online data charges. Possible peering partners for public libraries include other library sectors, government agencies, community groups and online database vendors.
  • Development of standard metrics and reporting of library data usage and sharing of benchmarking data is crucial for future planning for libraries
  • As data sources are becoming richer and more interactive, both rural and metropolitan libraries will require increased bandwidth capacity - existing internet grade DSL offerings will not be sufficient for future requirements.

Department of Communications, Information Technology and the Arts - National Broadband Strategy (Helen McLaren and Peter Huta)

Under the National Broadband Strategy, $142.8million has been allocated over four years from 2003-04 to a number of programs, based in the principle of government intervention where the market is not delivering developments in infrastructure and services:

  • Higher Bandwidth Incentive Scheme (HiBIS) - this delivers a direct subsidy per customer to service providers. Government funded libraries are not eligible, but not-for profit organisations (eg Friend of libraries) are.
  • Demand aggregation activities - are focused on education and health nationally and for each state/territory except ACT and Tasmania. The education program is focused on improving high bandwidth connectivity and speed between education related networks and it would be worth exploring peering arrangements and ways of integrating libraries more effectively with these networks through the National Broadband adviser and funding for a broker.
  • Infrastructure seed funding for regional, rural and remote areas

Peter Huta mentioned work underway in DCITA on developing strategies for improving the sustainability/viability of online access centres (OACs). This is a Government initiative in response to a recommendation of the Regional Telecommunications Inquiry. This work highlights that many OACs are likely to be encountering similar challenges to many public libraries in terms of community demand for and use of public internet facilities (eg usage costs). Peter noted that public libraries and OACs might wish to consider their aggregated connectivity needs and possible alliances.

Telstra (Carolyn Hough and Paul Smith)

Telstra is trying to be proactive in following the recommendations of the Senate Libraries in the online environment review. Telstra does not believe that the Universal Service Obligation approach is the most useful for considering universal access because of differing service needs. Telstra's entry point level for broadband is 256/64K, but bandwidth requirements are dependent on the applications used.

The broadband demand register allows communities to register their interest in having access to broadband. Once a certain level of interest is registered, Telstra will install ADSL at the exchange. As HiBIS develops, the number of expression of interest needed for ASDL installation will drop.

It was suggested that libraries could have a role as community champions of the broadband demand register.

Centre for Community Networking Research (Don Schauder)

CCNR's focus is on community informatics and community building. It has a program of action research on community information initiatives. CCNR co-ordinated the development of the Australian civil society statement for the World Summit on the Information Society. The notion of civil society is intense civic engagement with issues such as democratic pluralities, spatial isolation, inclusion, content and technology and effective use. The more this engagement is developed, the more it takes pressure off government service delivery. We are now seeing the second generation of community information initiatives. New forms of community knowledge generation and sharing need better integration into the more formal structures such as libraries and other cultural organisations. Until now, libraries have been at the margins of community knowledge sharing. A key role for libraries and library networks could be in ensuring the quality and ongoing accessibility of community generated online content.

Australian Local Government Association (Rick Molony)

Through NTN local government funding, ALGA and the state/territory local government associations have been working to improve interoperability across jurisdictions. A framework for heads of agreement for joined-up government projects has been developed and a toolkit identifies best practice examples of collaborative projects. A local government services thesaurus has been developed and an information architecture for local government is being developed. These projects are improving the capacity of local government to participate in cross-jurisdictional projects and processes. ALGA is looking to develop a national approach to local government news and a calendar of events using RSS and a services portal for local government that will aggregate data from federal, state and local government authorities relevant to local government.

National Library of Australia (Warwick Cathro)

The National Library's interest is in discovery and delivery of information resources, both in the content and the infrastructure to provide access to resources. The Library has a role in digital content collection building and in facilitating access through collaboration. The Community Heritage Grants program supports local and community collections. The AskNow collaborative reference service has a high level of demand from rural and regional areas. Australian Museums Online (AMOL) is now administered by the Powerhouse Museum. It's possible expansion to cover libraries and archives needs to be considered.

Australian Taxation Office (Charu Sood)

As more government information and transactions are available online, there are opportunities for partnerships with public libraries in delivering services and in providing community education and support.

Council of Australian State Libraries (Margaret Hyland and Lucy Arundell)

After a period when funding has been concentrated on developing infrastructure, CASL's focus is moving to development of and access to content. However, CASL has continued to work for the extension of online infrastructure for public libraries in rural, regional and remote communities through the CASL submission to the Senate enquiry and the establishment of Public Libraries Australia Ltd. In 2003, CASL's key priorities included:

  • Strengthening the national information infrastructure through cross sectoral collaboration through participation in the Kinetica Advisory Committee and in the IT-19 Standards Committee
  • Enhancing access to Australian cultural collection through support and participation in Picture Australia, the Australian Pictorial Thesaurus and the AskNow pilot project.
  • Extending the range of online information resources to the community through the establishment of Indigenous Knowledge Centres in Queensland and the Northern Territory. The CASL consortium assists CASL members to purchase access to online databases and the CASL Electronic Multicultural Library Services Working Group has been established.

Through the 'Australian Library Treasures' exhibition approved for 2005-2007, CASL is implementing a plan to make accessible the nation's treasures. CASL is also implementing a new national plan to ensure that there is ongoing access to Australian newspapers and a National Newspaper Digitisation Project has been proposed.

CASL has participated in the National Resource Sharing Working Group to support the development of shared policies for more effective use of library collections. The @ your library campaign has been used to promote the role of libraries in lifelong learning and CASL has worked to enhance partnerships between the library, education and cultural sectors.

Council of Australian University Librarians (Diane Costello)

Links between university networks and the community are increasing. While much information is licensed and available to the university community only, universities are considering how to make the output of universities more accessible to the community and how best to deliver services to the community and to remote and distance students.

Australian Library and Information Association - Public Libraries Reference Group (Christine Mackenzie and Jennefer Nicholson)

In general, public libraries are reacting to community demand, rather than proactively managing online services. Many libraries do not have enough PCs. There are considerable challenges in making resources accessible, for example many public libraries do not have systems that allow single searches across multiple databases or linked searches from their online catalogues.

The Senate inquiry gives an opportunity for the sector to pursue the challenges thrown up by the recommendations and to find ways to use government strategies and initiatives for the benefit of the sector.


top


Program

Convenor: Christine Mackenzie

10.00am Welcome and LIW message from the Minister
Introductions
10.15am The brief - agreement on focus of discussions being issues around recommendation 7 of the Senate report; and related recommendations on digitisation, community networks and access to electronic information; any other matters for discussion.
10.30am - 12.30pm Presentations (15 minutes each) - models, programs, initiatives
VICNET, Telstra, CCNR, DCITA (Broadband and Access programs), Australian Local Government Association
Discussion session - setting the priorities for the library and information services sector
12.30 - 1.15pm Lunch
1.15 - 3.15pm Agreement session - initiatives to achieve the priorities
3.15 - 3.30pm coffee/tea break
3.30 Wrap up and confirmation of participants in initiatives to make more information available more easily and efficiently to more Australians
4.00pm Close and thanks

top


Delegates

Christine Mackenzie - Convener

ALIA Past President
CEO, Yarra-Plenty Regional Library
ceo@yprl.vic.gov.au

Professor Don Schauder

Chair, Centre for Community Networking Research and Associate Dean (Research)
Faculty of Information Technology
Monash University
don.schauder@sims.monash.edu.au

Paul Smith

General Manager of Business Development
Telstra Country Wide
paul.x.smith@team.telstra.com

Carolyn Hough

Public Policy Manager, Regulatory Strategy,
Telstra Corporation Limited
carolyn.hough@team.telstra.com

Dr Warwick Cathro

Assistant Director-General, Innovation
National Library of Australia
wcathro@nla.gov.au

Michael Bertie

Director, Information Management
State Library of Victoria/VICNET

David Feighan

ISP Trading
VICNET
david@vicnet.net.au

Charu Sood

Executive Director for Information Services
Australian Taxation Office
Charu.sood@ato.gov.au

Rick Molony

Director, Online Services
Australian Local Government Association
rick.molony@alga.asn.au

Helen McLaren

Manager
Connectivity Strategy and Policy section
Department of Communications, IT and the Arts
Helen.McLaren@dcita.gov.au

Peter Huta

Manager, Community Connectivity
Access Branch
Information Economy Division
Department of Communications, IT and the Arts
Peter.Huta@dcita.gov.au

Lucy Arundell

Assistant State Librarian, Electronic Library Services
State Library of NSW (CASL)
larundell@sl.nsw.gov.au

Margaret Hyland

Manager, Public Library Services
ACT Library and Information Service (CASL)
Margaret.hyland@act.gov.au

Diane Costello

Executive Officer
Council of Australian University Librarians
Diane.Costello@caul.edu.au

Jennefer Nicholson

Executive Director
Australian Library and Information Association
Jennefer.Nicholson@alia.org.au

Susan Magnay

Manager, planning policy
Australian Library and Information Association
Susan.magnay@alia.org.au

Apologies

Lynne Makin
Public Libraries Australia LTD


top

l back
ALIA logo http://www.alia.org.au/advocacy/alw/2004/liw.forum.2004.html
© ALIA [ feedback | update | site map | privacy ] it.jb 4:15pm 20 July 2004